Review: Disney’s “The Odd Life of Timothy Green” is indeed odd, in all the wrong ways

in Disney, Movies, Reviews


Walt Disney once said, “Life is composed of lights and shadows, and we would be untruthful, insincere, and saccharine if we tried to pretend there were no shadows.” That might be a surprising quote from a man known for his uplifting family films, but it’s one of the secrets to Walt’s amazing story sense. It’s a secret the filmmakers behind “The Odd Life of Timothy Green” would have greatly benefited from.

Opening today, August 15, 2012, “The Odd Life of Timothy Green” is about a happily married couple (Jennifer Garner and Joel Edgerton) who are unable to have children. In an effort to move on, they describe in detail what their kid would have been like. They write all of these attributes down and bury them in the garden. Later that night, the child they described shows up at their doorstep. His name is Timothy and he has leaves growing out of his legs.

All of that takes place in the first 10 minutes. Up until that point it’s a wonderfully acted and emotional family drama. I was in tears when the doctor tells them they’ve done all they can — very reminiscent of Pixar’s “Up.”

Unfortunately, once Timothy shows up, the film takes a huge tonal shift and everyone becomes dumb.

The next day, they go about integrating Timothy into their life and no one seems to question where he came from at all. Oh they ask of course, but everyone is satisfied with really lame answers. Even if you’re not familiar with the almost always excruciatingly long adoption process, it’s a good bet most people realize you don’t find out you’re infertile one day and welcome an adopted child into your home the next.

From there the film meanders from scene to scene without any sort of dramatic urgency. Timothy himself never feels like a real boy and comes off more than a little creepy at times. It hits on several big ideas and themes but never really settles on one. I’m not really sure what the film is about.

I suppose it could be compared to Mary Poppins in its structure, but Poppins has this great sadness underneath and some truly dark moments. “The Odd Life of Timothy Green” has some moments that should have been dark, but they choose to play them like it’s just another thing that happened.

On the bright side, Garner and Edgerton do a fine job with weak material, and the cinematography was beautiful. It really captured an idyllic small town feel that was nice to look at, but I don’t think it served the story well. It’s such and odd (there, I said it) story that it would have been much better suited to a Tim Burton fantasy style aesthetic.

Overall it’s a film that’s just a little too sweet. I admire what they were going for, but they just didn’t achieve it. Instead of a touching movie exploring some of life’s biggest issues and themes, it’s “untruthful, insincere, and saccharine.” Let’s hope they learn from Walt on the next one.


  1. Shelley Ziegler

    i dont know if i will see this movie or not..but i do find it interesting that you talk about Disney being “known for his uplifting family films” In general, Disney films usually do have a really dark undertone..most of it revolving around the loss of a mother or father. Just a short list..starting right at the beginning..Snow White, Bambi, Cinderella, and even motherless Peter Pan. To the more recent Lion King, Finding Nemo and Up. What is it with Disneys obsession with orphans??

    1. True, Shelley. Here’s the entire Walt Disney quote I referenced in the review:

      “I don’t believe in playing down to children, either in life or in motion pictures. I didn’t treat my own youngsters like fragile flowers, and I think no parent should.
      Children are people, and they should have to reach to learn about things, to understand things, just as adults have to reach if they want to grow in mental stature. Life is composed of lights and shadows, and we would be untruthful, insincere, and saccharine if we tried to pretend there were no shadows. Most things are good, and they are the strongest things; but there are evil things too, and you are not doing a child a favor by trying to shield him from reality. The important thing is to teach a child that good can always triumph over evil, and that is what our pictures attempt to do.”

Add Your Voice